Bid leveling.
Like for like, then a recommendation.

How to put contractor bids on a common basis, check the arithmetic, carry alternates separately and recommend to the owner, with an ArchX test project.

How do you level construction bids?

Check each bid’s arithmetic against its own line items, then put every bid on the same scope: price what one bidder includes and another excludes, treat allowances and permit fees the same way, carry alternates separately and compare against your estimate. The leveled amounts, not the submitted totals, show the real order. Open points become questions to the bidders, and the result becomes your recommendation to the owner, who makes the award.

A bid with a hole in it

When a bid leaves out part of the scope or leaves it unpriced, you can only compare it if you value the gap. Add a comparison plug: the median of the other bids for that line, or a stated basis such as the sales tax rate. Show it next to the unchanged leveled total and the rank of complete bids, and mark it for comparison only: it is neither the bidder’s price nor an approved adjustment. Whether a bid is responsive stays a separate question.

What moves the ranking

The lowest submitted bid is often not the lowest bid. These points usually decide it:

  • Arithmetic: the stated total does not match the sum of the line items.
  • Exclusions, such as equipment piping left to the owner’s vendor.
  • Allowances carried by one bidder and not by another.
  • Permit fees included in one bid and excluded in another.
  • Schedule: a lower price on a longer schedule may miss the owner’s date.

What goes to the owner

The submitted and leveled amounts side by side, how each adjustment was made, alternates shown separately, the comparison with your estimate, each bidder’s schedule, the questions still open and a recommendation, conditional where the open points require it. The owner awards the contract; your letter gives a clear basis.

How to do it.

  1. 01

    Check the arithmetic

    Line items against each stated total.

  2. 02

    Align the scope

    Allowances, exclusions and fees on the same basis.

  3. 03

    Separate alternates

    Carry them apart from the base bids.

  4. 04

    Compare

    Against your estimate and the owner’s schedule.

  5. 05

    Recommend

    Leveling workbook, evaluation report and letter to the owner.

A test project: three bids for a tenant improvement in Dallas.

Three fictitious bids and the Instructions to Bidders in the project folder, one request to ArchX: back came the bid tab, a leveling review, an evaluation report and a draft letter to the owner. The lowest bid was not the lowest once its exclusions were valued, and the recommendation stayed subject to the bond and the open checks.

Bid leveling review: three bids with submitted, checked and leveled totals, scope and rank, leveled including plugs with a comparison rank, and below them Alternate No. 1 with each bidder's price, one marked as not counted as zero
Bid leveling review: three bids with submitted, checked and leveled totals, scope and rank, leveled including plugs with a comparison rank, and below them Alternate No. 1 with each bidder's price, one marked as not counted as zero
Comparison plugs: sprinklers at the median of the other two bids and sales tax on the bid, each with its basis and its assumptions, headed for comparison only
Comparison plugs: sprinklers at the median of the other two bids and sales tax on the bid, each with its basis and its assumptions, headed for comparison only
6 min 21 s

ArchX working time, measured

$436,266.75

is the estimated comparison amount for the lowest bid, $389,900, once the sprinklers and sales tax it excluded are in, with the basis shown

$412,600

the apparent low responsive bidder, subject to its bond. The lowest bid has four exceptions; the other lower bid left a mandatory alternate unpriced, which the owner may waive only if the documents allow it

Test project: U.S., with planted errors. A fictitious tenant improvement in Dallas, a fictitious firm and owner and three contractors named Example. One run with ChatGPT Pro (GPT 6.1 Sol, very high) and the code of ArchX 0.1.4. See the whole result

Asked briefly.

Does ArchX read bids as PDF?

Yes. In the test project all three bids and the Instructions to Bidders came as PDF.

Does ArchX award the contract?

No. ArchX levels the bids and drafts the report and the letter; the firm checks and signs, and the owner awards.

How long does it take?

In the test project 6 min 21 s of ArchX working time, measured, for one request.

Try it on your own work.

Download ArchX for Mac or Windows and give it a task from your firm. 7 days free with your ChatGPT account (Plus or higher).